09-07-2010, 01:58 PM
(09-07-2010, 06:02 AM)PB BB1 Wrote: Regardless of who has said what where, I do think that dark blue resin-cast X shares a lineage to the production Pyros and not the MB. This is a strictly visual comparison. Things we never see in any replica or rocket. The unmodified cockpit. You can just barely make it out from the photos. The wing blocks as well, there is the notched line that covers the gap on the inside along with matching chipping pattern. This matches the Pyro master that went for auction. Production lineage is not in question IMO. Death star surface tiles reveal cast wing greeblies perfectly matching the wings that go with that master. Sure I guess someone could have had access to these production parts without a fuselage, I'll give you that. However, to me this just doesn't seem likely. Visual tells alone indicate this set in its entirety shares some lineage to a Pyro, even if it is one generation removed from its halved construction.I'm not angry with you Paul, please don't think I was attacking you. I don't want you to be tainted with the vitriol that the rpf, or other forums have on them regularly.
I get it. Build my own, make it how I see it. I will. I don't want anyone to have the perception that I'm self proclaimed savior of the illusive ANH X. I'm not. Nearly all of the part IDs had been made when I started this last year, and many subtleties of the form have just become obvious to me. These are JUST models at the end of the day. I think we all have common goals and projects we want to see turn out with the best of all information available. I'll probably never take on a project like this again. There is nothing else I'm interested in as much, and I'd simply lack the motivation to complete other projects of this scale.
Yeah, a lot of tough crowd over there on the RPF but I still believe were just a bunch of guys trying to help each other out. I do not see it as a rivalry or competition. Agree to disagree on the above master, Chris. That said, I'm not picking a fight. PM me your address and I'll send you a stormtrooper.
I truly like you, and you are one of the few people I respect, not for what you've done, but because who you are. You've impressed upon me that you do care about other people, not just as members of the modeling forums, but people in general. This is what gravitated me to you. You are indeed talented, and we all have our bad days, or days where someone said something that we didn't like, or agree with, but you've always given me the emotional push I need without being sarcastic, or hateful. This is why I'm fighting so hard to keep you here on SSM as much as possible. I know that there are a few genuinely concerned people on the rpf, but it seems the rest of them like to dogpile each other when disagreements arise. We take care of it like adults here, and not keep rubbing salt into an open wound, or announcing how we banned someone like we're the Jesus Christ of the modeling forums, and we've saved the world from evil.
Banning is something that is only reserved when all other means have been exausted, it's not something we're proud of! This is not something you want your forum to be known for, so we all tip toe when conflicts arise to diffuse them as quickly as possible - not rub our members' faces in it.After carefully looking at this X master again, I see what you mean about the details, but someone would have to be cunning enough to replicate this X master so exactly to original specs. Maybe someone made one like this, and has recast it, and it's made its' rounds the world over. I highly doubt that someone would make one to fool people, but I've seen it happen before - but maybe not with this one. After seeing this, and comparing it to known models, it seems highly unlikely. The Salzo kit has the same zig-zag pattern along the wing openings in the fuselage, but that wouldn't account for the size differences, as I have a Salzo kit, but it definately doesn't compare to the fuselage with the black primer on it.
I believe that with the research you're doing that the X you've made will be one to own, even if it isn't the Holy grail of kits, or claimed to be. I know that with your passion, attention to detail, and drive that this will please all who own one, and I have the utmost confidence that it'll be accurate enough to make us all proud. I need your strength to keep going on my own X-project. I've been waiting for this for so long. I'm finally able to see one of these go from scratch to finished project that will be offered to all. I'm willing to help where I can. I understand not wanting to make one of these again, the four foot X will the only one of its' size I'll ever make. This is something I definately won't repeat, therefore this has to be spot on!
On the X-wing pictured: it was primered in black as the rest of the X's were (even though it looks blue in the light) - you can tell this from the white spots on the nosecone, and the plate before the side mount. That doesn't mean that it doesn't have the same lineage, but why doesn't it have the cockpit canopy?
(09-07-2010, 09:27 AM)jasonwright.1972 Wrote: You could make tiles for your toilet or something? I must try this. I think I shall build a vaccuform box on the weekend. the Dyson vaccuum should work a treat at that task!Don't get me started, Jase - I was thinking about making tiles with stormtrooper reliefs on them to cover my bathroom walls! I'd love to have a vacuum former - the possibilities are endless......maybe a 12" inch stormtrooper doll for each of the vanity doors, and 3" 3/4 for the walls? Paul you are a genius! I don't know how you did this with the stormtrooper being so small, because the smaller an item is - the harder it is to get the details to come out so clean, but you nailed it perfectly!!
~ Cobra Chris


![[Image: fuselages03.jpg]](http://www.bitmeister.com/beaz/xwing/images/fuselages03.jpg)
![[Image: fuselages01.jpg]](http://www.bitmeister.com/beaz/xwing/images/fuselages01.jpg)
![[Image: fuselages02.jpg]](http://www.bitmeister.com/beaz/xwing/images/fuselages02.jpg)
![[Image: fusecomp03.jpg]](http://www.mindspring.com/~beazuhma/images/fusecomp03.jpg)
![[Image: pyro-salzo-v3-comp-01-sm.jpg]](http://www.bitmeister.com/beaz/xwing/images/pyro-salzo-v3-comp-01-sm.jpg)
![[Image: pyro-salzo-v3-comp-02-sm.jpg]](http://www.bitmeister.com/beaz/xwing/images/pyro-salzo-v3-comp-02-sm.jpg)
This means that I got reamed by Frank, and everyone else for nothing! They claim this is a true pyro recast, and all others like it on the rpf in the DaveG thread about the orange X model purportedly cast from an original pyro, but it looks just like this one. Thank you once again, Beaz. You've shed a light on a dark path for all to see!
I dont know why ILM had CC recasts in their shop.
![[Image: cockpitrearwhatisit.jpg]](http://i305.photobucket.com/albums/nn227/budmataul/cockpitrearwhatisit.jpg)
![[Image: photo-4.jpg]](http://i305.photobucket.com/albums/nn227/budmataul/photo-4.jpg)
![[Image: helpmeidthisbeotch.jpg]](http://i305.photobucket.com/albums/nn227/budmataul/helpmeidthisbeotch.jpg)
![[Image: curious.jpg]](http://i305.photobucket.com/albums/nn227/budmataul/curious.jpg)
![[Image: hasegawakarloneseventytwo.jpg]](http://i305.photobucket.com/albums/nn227/budmataul/hasegawakarloneseventytwo.jpg)
![[Image: cppartsID.jpg]](http://i305.photobucket.com/albums/nn227/budmataul/cppartsID.jpg)
![[Image: partodd.jpg]](http://i305.photobucket.com/albums/nn227/budmataul/partodd.jpg)
![[Image: photo-6.jpg]](http://i305.photobucket.com/albums/nn227/budmataul/photo-6.jpg)